Back to Blog
Buying Guides 2026-11-17 Art of Play - Playing Cards, Puzzles and Amusements 5 views

Cylinder, Box, Dial or Cross: Which Pocket Puzzle to Buy?

Cylinder, Box, Dial or Cross: Which Pocket Puzzle to Buy?

Four Hanayama-style metal pocket puzzles, compared by difficulty, mechanism and price so you can pick the right small mechanical puzzle or travel gift.

Start with how the puzzle comes apart

These four pocket puzzles all fit in a hand and share a metal build, but they ask for different kinds of thinking. Cylinder and Dial are sequence puzzles: you work through a hidden order of moves. Box is a spatial maze with a ring to free. Cross is a notched-piece puzzle that rotates and revolves once you find the hidden joints. Matching that mechanism to the solver matters more than the price gap.

The catalog also gives difficulty for two of the four. Cylinder and Dial are both rated Level 5, Expert. Box is described as tricky but not terrible, and Cross is pitched at beginner to intermediate puzzlers. That leaves a clear split: two expert-rated locks and two more approachable designs.

What the catalog confirms about the two expert-rated puzzles

  • Cylinder Pocket Puzzle: Cylinder is a pseudo-combination lock: five metal pieces must be twisted, pushed and pulled in the perfect sequence to come apart, and listening carefully may reveal a clue to the hidden mechanisms inside. This is an auditory, sequence-based challenge, so it suits a solver who enjoys patience and careful observation rather than speed.
    Cylinder Pocket Puzzle
    Cylinder Pocket Puzzle
  • Dial Pocket Puzzle: Dial is solved by turning dials on both front and back, and the solution requires more than just moving forward — sometimes moving a step back is important. The two-sided dial mechanism adds a spatial wrinkle, making it a good pick for someone who likes combination-lock logic.
    Dial Pocket Puzzle
    Dial Pocket Puzzle

The two more approachable designs

  • Box Pocket Puzzle: Box is a three-dimensional maze: free the silver ring from the brass box, with unexpected twists and turns around every corner. It is also suggested as a good choice for a puzzle race with friends. The race angle makes Box a social puzzle, and the maze format gives immediate feedback as you explore.
  • Cross Pocket Puzzle: Cross is a two-tone square with a plus sign subtracted from the middle; hidden notches let the pieces rotate and revolve in surprising directions, and it is described as a good choice for beginner to intermediate puzzlers. This is the lowest-frustration entry point of the four, with a visual, tactile mechanism that rewards experimentation.

Side by side: difficulty, mechanism and price

Prices are catalog prices at the time of writing and may change. All four list a comparison price of USD 17.00.

  • Cylinder Pocket Puzzle — USD 12.58: Level 5, Expert. Pseudo-combination lock with five metal pieces; listening for clues is part of the solve. Designed by Vesa Timonen, produced by Hanayama.
  • Dial Pocket Puzzle — USD 12.75: Level 5, Expert. Two-sided dials; the solution requires moving backward as well as forward. Designed by Vesa Timonen, produced by Hanayama.
  • Box Pocket Puzzle — USD 10.20: Difficulty not rated in the catalog; described as tricky but not terrible. Three-dimensional maze to free a silver ring from a brass box; good for puzzle races. Designed by Akira Yuta, produced by Hanayama.
  • Cross Pocket Puzzle — USD 10.71: Beginner to intermediate. Two-tone notched pieces that rotate and revolve. Designed by Edi Nagata.

Match the puzzle to the solver

  • For a confident solver who wants a real challenge: Cylinder or Dial. Both are rated Level 5, Expert, so expect a longer solve and more trial and error. Cylinder leans on careful listening and sequence; Dial leans on two-sided dial logic.
  • For a beginner or a younger puzzler: Cross. The catalog places it at beginner to intermediate, and the hidden notches make it forgiving to explore.
  • For a group or a friendly competition: Box. The catalog specifically suggests it for a puzzle race, and the maze format gives everyone something to watch.
  • For a travel gift or a pocket companion: All four are pocket-sized metal puzzles. Dial is also described as doubling as a fidget toy, which may appeal to someone who wants a desk object as well as a puzzle.

What the catalog does not settle

Age ranges and safety warnings are not supplied for these four puzzles, so check the packaging or product page before buying for a child. Solve times are not given, and difficulty ratings are only listed for Cylinder and Dial. Box and Cross have descriptive difficulty language but no numbered level. If you need a specific level to complete a set, the catalog does not confirm it for those two.

Materials are listed as metal for Cylinder and Dial, and the others are described as metal in the product details. Exact dimensions are only supplied for Cylinder at approximately 2 x 2 inches. For the rest, treat the pocket-size description as a general guide rather than a precise measurement.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile